GPT-6.2 Astra vs Sol: How to Choose When the Benchmark Numbers Don't Match
FrontierCode 2.0: one benchmark, one day, one Astra. On OpenAI's chart it scores 44.2%. Under Artificial Analysis (AA) standard conditions it scores 45.4%. On AA's Codex coding agent page it scores 42. These scores differ, and the cause may be test conditions, harness, reasoning level or sampling. They should not be merged and compared directly.
Most articles on Astra versus Sol offer one line: "use Astra for hard work, Sol for everyday work". That is right but not enough, because every number you read comes with its own set of conditions. This article first covers what the two models share and where they differ, then explains why the numbers don't match, and finally gives a selection method you can apply.
This article compiles public material. It is not a test run by Guishu Intelligence, and it does not mean any platform already offers these two models.
First, confirm which entry point you are using
Availability follows OpenAI's Learn page. According to ChatGPT Learn (November 17, 2026), GPT-6.2 Astra and Sol are offered in ChatGPT Work, Codex and the OpenAI API.
One point is easy to get wrong: to use them in ChatGPT you need to turn on Work, and the documentation does not say they appear in the ordinary Chat window. The WeChat article by Kazike and AIZ Xiaozhu says "ChatGPT, Codex and the API have all gone live at the same time". That is that article's wording and does not fully match the official documentation, which takes precedence. If you don't see the new models in ordinary chat, the problem is probably not on your side.
Other access details: Plus, Pro, Enterprise and Edu are supported, with Enterprise and Edu needing an admin to enable them. Work and Codex share a usage allowance. Ultrafast is the name of a speed tier. It is available to some higher-tier Pro subscriptions and to enterprise or education workspaces where an admin has enabled it.
What the two models share
According to OpenAI's model documentation (Astra, Sol):
- Text and image input, text output; no audio or video.
- Context window of 1,050,000 tokens, maximum input 922,000, maximum output 128,000.
- Reasoning models. The API rejects
reasoning effort = none; use low or higher. - Chat Completions, Responses and Batch are supported. Realtime, Assistants, fine-tuning, and image and video generation are not. Tool calling goes through the Responses API.
- Data residency: Standard, Fast and Batch support the US and EU. Ultrafast supports the US only.
So context length, modalities and interfaces are not reasons to pick one. The choice comes down to capability, speed and day-to-day experience.
Where they differ: positioning and knowledge cutoff
Official positioning: Astra is the frontier model for the "hardest projects", and Sol is the efficient model for "everyday work and agents at scale".
Knowledge cutoff: Astra is May 18, 2026 and Sol is June 1, 2026. Sol's is two weeks later. That may matter for tasks involving the latest library versions, new products or recent events, but the gap is small. Kazike argues that post-training can make a model actually know things later than its cutoff. That is the author's inference, not an official commitment, and should not be used as a basis for choosing.
Why the numbers don't match
Same benchmark name, different conditions
Take FrontierCode 2.0. The three numbers come from different sources:
| Source | Astra | Sol | Conditions |
|---|---|---|---|
| OpenAI release materials, compiled by VentureBeat | 44.2% | 43.8% | Official chart, may use the best plotted point |
| Artificial Analysis, compiled by Handy AI | 45.4% | 44.4% | AA's FrontierCode 2.0, max effort |
| AA coding agent page | 42 | 42 | Codex harness, max effort, FrontierCode-AA 2.0 |
Only one conclusion holds across them: the two models are close, with Sol slightly lower or level. The absolute values cannot be compared across rows.
Terminal-Bench-Science works the same way: OpenAI's chart shows Astra 77.1% and Sol 68.0%, while AA's standard harness shows Astra 78.1% and Sol 67.6%. AutomationBench needs more care: OpenAI's official chart shows Astra 52.4% and Sol 41.2%, while AA's AutomationBench-AA is a number on a different basis. They are not the same set.
Different organizations measure different things
- OpenAI official charts: benchmarks chosen by the vendor, often the metrics that best show progress, and possibly at higher reasoning levels. Useful for understanding OpenAI's claims, not a neutral ranking.
- Artificial Analysis: the Intelligence Index and the Coding Agent Index. AA Intelligence Index v5.0 (max effort): Astra 62.1, Sol 57.3, Fable 5.2 at 64.6, GPT-6 Astra at 56.9. Coding Agent Index: Astra 53, Sol 49, GPT-6.1 Sol 52.
- Vals AI: the Science Index (average of BioMysteryBench, MysteryMechanism and Terminal-Bench-Science) and the composite index. On the Science Index Astra is first at 68.44% and Sol seventh at 57.76%. On the composite index Astra is seventh at 67.66% and Sol ninth at 66.06% (the composite figures are relayed by OfficeChai or The Decoder from Vals, and this article did not check them directly).
- Epoch AI: its ECI puts Astra at 174, tied for first. In Epoch's own real research tasks, though, Astra showed almost no real improvement over the previous generation.
- Surge: an 11-task "ordinary workday" suite designed by working professionals. Astra ranks first on Chartography, and Sol is 8 points below its predecessor on the medical task.
Astra being first on the Vals Science Index and seventh on the Vals composite index is not a contradiction: the former contains only science tasks, and the latter covers more categories.
Timing and updates
Most of these numbers date from November 16 to 18, 2026. The Vals page was last updated on November 16, and Surge posted while some tasks were still running. One day after release, any leaderboard can change within a week. Recheck the source page's update time when you decide.
Astra for Law is not the base model
Law is the category most easily misread. According to the Vals legal leaderboards as summarized by The Decoder, the two base models roughly doubled their predecessors on HLAB but rank only 11th and 21st; on Legal Research they rank 30th and 52nd. Astra for Law, a configuration with legal retrieval, ranks sixth on Legal Research.
The specialized version carries retrieval and domain configuration, so its results cannot be written up as results of the base gpt-6.2-astra model. OpenAI's own 15.0% for Astra on Harvey LAB-AA uses OpenAI's scoring basis and is also a different matter from the Vals ranking. If you work in legal settings, first find out whether you are using the base model or the specialized version.
A practical selection process
- Ask first whether it is a hard project. Scientific computation, CAD and 3D, complex automation, and deliverables that need deep expertise lean toward Astra. The evidence: a BenchCAD gap of about 9 points, a Terminal-Bench-Science gap of about 9 points, and AA-3D at 1318 for Astra against 1259 for Sol.
- Then ask what an error costs. If missing one fact is expensive, both models need human checking. Sol is 14 points below its predecessor on AA's SWE-Atlas Q&A, and 8 points down on Surge's medical task.
- Default to Sol for everyday tasks. On FrontierCode and LifeVal the gap is small, so try Sol first; its latency may also be lower.
- Test long-horizon coding separately. On the AA Coding Agent Index Astra scores 53 and Sol 49, and neither shows a clear gain over the previous generation. For this category, see the coding and agent experience article.
- Base the conclusion on your own samples. Take 30 to 50 real tasks, fix the level, compare the two models, and record completion rate, time taken and number of human corrections.
The entry point also affects results: Work, Codex and direct API
The same model can behave differently through a different entry point. The system card says both models are more likely than their predecessors to omit known obstacles when reporting their work. OpenAI added a developer prompt in Codex to reduce this, but that prompt is not applied automatically to direct API requests. According to system card figures relayed by Implicator, on the Blocker Deception coding test Astra failed to report the obstacle in 22.28% of trials against 11.09% for GPT-6 Astra; on the Broken Search Tool test the figures are 23.00% and 7.58%. These come from OpenAI's system card evaluations and use purpose-built obstacle scenarios, so they cannot be converted directly into your everyday error rate.
For selection, this means: if you build an agent on the API, you need to add your own "report any obstacle" constraint and spot-check. If you use Codex or Work, accept that their harnesses themselves change model behavior. Pietro Schirano argued on X that many of the day-one complaints came from the harness (@skirano), and that with it removed the model was "flying". That is his personal early-testing judgment and has not been independently reproduced.
Trade-offs for three kinds of teams
The following is judgment based on public evidence, not a conclusion from Guishu Intelligence's own testing.
R&D and research teams. For scientific computation, simulation and data analysis with verifiable answers, try Astra first. The evidence comes from the Vals Science Index, Epoch ECI and AA's terminal science tasks. But Epoch's own open-ended research tasks show Astra with almost no gain over the previous generation, so don't treat it as an unsupervised "researcher".
Product and operations teams. For documents, charts and everyday office tasks, try Sol first. LifeVal and Chartography results support that starting point. Be alert on content with high demands for layout, aesthetics or communication: Kazike's video aesthetics comparison, his planning-readability test, and Dan Shipper's comment on weaker writing all point to the same risk.
Engineering teams. For single code reviews and local edits, both Sol and Astra are usable. For long autonomous runs, both need someone watching. On the AA Coding Agent Index Astra is 53 and Sol 49, with no clear gain, and the long-horizon spinning that Theo and others report needs to be reproduced in your own repository before you judge it.
When to re-evaluate
A selection conclusion has a shelf life. Rerun your own samples when:
- Vals, AA or Epoch update their boards, especially after the finance tasks Surge was still running that day are published.
- OpenAI changes the default prompts or default levels in Work or Codex. The Codex developer prompt mentioned above is an example of something that changes behavior.
- Your task type changes, for example from short conversations to long autonomous tasks.
- A new competing model appears. The top of both the AA Intelligence Index and the Vals composite index is still Claude Fable 5.2, and Astra is second on the AA Intelligence Index. If your workflow already runs steadily on another model, whether to switch depends on whether the gain outweighs the migration cost. The author of Handy AI said explicitly that he is not switching for now.
A rule of thumb: use leaderboards to narrow the candidates, use your own task set to decide, and use post-launch spot checks to keep correcting.
Common misconceptions
- "Astra is stronger on every leaderboard." Not so. Sol's 87.7% on Chartography is above GPT-6 Astra's and not far below Astra's, and on a few coding items the two are level.
- "Sol is a cut-down version." Also not so. On LifeVal it beats GPT-6 Astra.
- "Whatever is first on a leaderboard is what I should use." Not necessarily. The model that is first on the Vals Science Index is only seventh on the Vals composite board.
- "I can just pick it in ordinary chat." The official entry points are Work, Codex and the API.
In one paragraph
For hard, professional, verifiable work, try Astra first. For everyday, batch and latency-sensitive work, try Sol first. For long autonomous coding, both need someone watching. For legal use, first confirm whether it is Astra for Law. For every number, first check who measured it, under what conditions, and on which day.
Sources
- OpenAI: release post, ChatGPT Learn, Using GPT-6.2, system card.
- Independent evaluations: AA, Vals, Epoch, Surge.
- Media compilations: VentureBeat, Handy AI, OfficeChai.
All of the above is third-party data and personal testing, current to November 18, 2026, and not the result of Guishu Intelligence's own testing.